Philosophy Forums
Forums Links Articles Gallery Chat
Style:



Register | Forgot Password

So, what's freedom, again?

printPrint


Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6

So, what's freedom, again?
Dan_Browne
Student

Usergroup: Members
Joined: Mar 15, 2004
Location: Alberta
Total Topics: 4
Total Posts: 81
Posted 03/25/04 - 07:00 PM:
quote post
#1
I understand that those of us living under western governments have the privilidge to be residing in a free nation. But is our freedom free?

We have Taxes, we have brutal police, we have society. And I realise that these things are very small compared to that of other lands.

freeˇdom - The condition of being free of restraints.

I want to not be a part of the society I live and I would rather be as independant as i possibly can. But it seems that we always have to be making money and we always have to be giving that money to someone else.

I'd appreciate hearing what everyone else thinks freedom really is.

There's no government like no government.
top mosker
banned

Usergroup: Members
Joined: Dec 01, 2003 >
Location: over there --->
Total Topics: 43
Total Posts: 722
Posted 03/25/04 - 08:45 PM:
quote post
#2
What we have in America is hardly freedom.
The scary part is that we are raised to believe we do.

Maybe you aren't bothered by the freedom that is restricted. Maybe you don't really care about the drug war, or the lethal use of force, or tax reform, but these are things that we have come to accept as necessity, when they are the foundations of a totalitarian government masquerading as a democracy. The fascists don't call themselves fascists.


"...The eternal charade of the middle-class intellectuals - Behold my wings! Freedom! Flight! - but you don't actually expect me to jump off that cliff, do you?" - Tom Wolfe The Electric Kool Aid Acid Test
Alan
Aspirant

Usergroup: Members
Joined: Feb 09, 2004
Location: Montreal
Total Topics: 1
Total Posts: 23
Posted 03/25/04 - 08:52 PM:
quote post
#3
top mosker wrote:
What we have in America is hardly freedom.
The scary part is that we are raised to believe we do.
I'd cautiously agree with you, but could you say how it could be more free?

"If you wait for luck to turn up, life becomes very boring."
-Mikhail Tal
Socrastein
Looking to understand
Avatar

Usergroup: Members
Joined: Jan 28, 2004
Location: A desolate sea of bollocks
Total Topics: 44
Total Posts: 2181
Posted 03/25/04 - 08:55 PM:
quote post
#4
What we have in America is hardly freedom.
The scary part is that we are raised to believe we do.


"None are so hopelessly enslaved as those who falsely believe they are free."

"The time has come for people of reason to say enough is enough. Religious faith discourages independent thought, it's devisive, and it's dangerous."
-Richard Dawkins
Gassendi1
banned

Usergroup: Sponsors
Joined: Jul 10, 2003
Total Topics: 152
Total Posts: 11022
Posted 03/25/04 - 09:59 PM:
quote post
#5
Socrastein wrote:
"None are so hopelessly enslaved as those who falsely believe they are free."

____________________________________________________
The scary part is that you seem to think that you can live in a civilization without any restraints at all. And, of course, that you think that freedom is absolute and not relative. You ought to try living in places like Saudi Arabia, or China, or Syria, for comparison with what we have in the United States.
softtarget
because
Avatar

Usergroup: Sponsors
Joined: Mar 17, 2004
Location: ininity
Total Topics: 56
Total Posts: 1514
Posted 03/25/04 - 10:13 PM:
quote post
#6
To paraphrase Ben Franklin: If you sacrifice freedom for safety, you shall have neither freedom nor safety.


softtarget

a journey to nothingness
Gassendi1
banned

Usergroup: Sponsors
Joined: Jul 10, 2003
Total Topics: 152
Total Posts: 11022
Posted 03/25/04 - 10:21 PM:
quote post
#7
softtarget wrote:
To paraphrase Ben Franklin: If you sacrifice freedom for safety, you shall have neither freedom nor safety.

______________________________________________________
Well, it seems to me that when we have traffic laws we are sacrificing freedom (driving as we please) for safety. But we could not drive safely without traffic laws, I think you would agree. Or, do you think that in the interests of freedom we should do away with traffic lights?

It helps to think concretely by examples, and forget about abstractions.
top mosker
banned

Usergroup: Members
Joined: Dec 01, 2003 >
Location: over there --->
Total Topics: 43
Total Posts: 722
Posted 03/25/04 - 10:32 PM:
quote post
#8
Alan wrote:
I'd cautiously agree with you, but could you say how it could be more free?


Freedom would be the abscence of unnecessary laws. Our judicial system is downright rediculous. I refer to Tacitus for his opinion on the matter: "The more corrupt the republic, the more numerous the laws." It takes entire libraries to hold all the laws we must obey. You draw the conclusions.

Freedom would give the minority a voice. See Thoreau for his opinions on the apathy of the majority. I refer to A. Hoffman: "You measure democracy by the freedom it gives its dissidents, not the freedom it gives its assimilated conformists." We lock those that speak out against the government in institutions as criminals or insane men. And then we forget about them because the state tells us they are criminal and insane. No one wants to associate with a nutcase or a criminal...

Freedom would be government that has to answer to the people and was limited in size and especially power. We have no way to change matters because of the two political parties that have put a stranglehold on the American psyche. I refer to Jefferson: "Was the government to prescribe to us our medicine and diet, our bodies would be in such keeping as our souls are now." The bi-party system allows for those with power to raise issues instead of those that are intended to wield the power: the citizens of the United States. We have choice a or b. Where are the other 24 letters? Where are OUR letters? Fuck democrats and fuck republicans. They are different ends of the same beast. (I'll let you decide which one gets to be the poopchute.)

NONE of these issues are ever raised by our politicians because the people trust them to make the important descisions. And with trust, comes totalitarianism. For too long, we have stood idly by, while they reach ever so subtle towards complete control of our minds. Our apathy has stood for too long. There is no changing the system, only scrapping it for one based on freedom and the bill of rights.

Things like the PATRIOT act don't bother me because I see it as a mere symptom of the real problem - power. Take the power out of government and you have freedom.


"...The eternal charade of the middle-class intellectuals - Behold my wings! Freedom! Flight! - but you don't actually expect me to jump off that cliff, do you?" - Tom Wolfe The Electric Kool Aid Acid Test
softtarget
because
Avatar

Usergroup: Sponsors
Joined: Mar 17, 2004
Location: ininity
Total Topics: 56
Total Posts: 1514
Posted 03/25/04 - 10:32 PM:
quote post
#9
Gassendi1 wrote:
It helps to think concretely by examples, and forget about abstractions.


Point taken. However I do feel as though retoric serves to confuse the terms "safety and freedom" to the point that they are merged. That, I believe, is the point Franklin was trying to make.

Here's another forgetable paraphrased abstraction by D. Eisonhower: If it is absolute safety a nation strives for, then it's people might as well live in prison. At least there they will have a roof over their heads and regular meals.


softtarget

a journey to nothingness
top mosker
banned

Usergroup: Members
Joined: Dec 01, 2003 >
Location: over there --->
Total Topics: 43
Total Posts: 722
Posted 03/25/04 - 10:36 PM:
quote post
#10
Gassendi1 wrote:
______________________________________________________
Well, it seems to me that when we have traffic laws we are sacrificing freedom (driving as we please) for safety. But we could not drive safely without traffic laws, I think you would agree. Or, do you think that in the interests of freedom we should do away with traffic lights?

It helps to think concretely by examples, and forget about abstractions.

It helps to think what really is at stake here, and forget your learned ideas.

We could drive plenty safe without traffic laws. It's called 'personal responsibility.' You don't drive too fast so that you don't injure someone or yourself. You stop at intersections so you don't get in an accident.

When you have laws to think for you, what does that leave your mind to do?


"...The eternal charade of the middle-class intellectuals - Behold my wings! Freedom! Flight! - but you don't actually expect me to jump off that cliff, do you?" - Tom Wolfe The Electric Kool Aid Acid Test
Download thread as

Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6



You don't have permission to post.

Please login or register.

30 total queries
This page was created in 1.99 seconds
Memory used: 7916040 bytes
Server Status: time since last reboot is 246 days, 19:52, load average: 2.19, 1.85, 1.85